High school junior Aiden dreams of playing football and playing with his brother
Brandon, senior star quarterback on the school team in “All the Noise at Once” (Atheneum 2025) by DeAndra Davis.
Aiden’s family is wealthy, black, and lives in a mostly white community. Aiden is on the spectrum, and his big brother Brandon has always supported him, gotten him out of tight spots, and been there for him.
Aiden’s football tryout ends with the rest of the team piling on him and he freaks out. He’s talented and big and he makes the team, but will he ever get to be out on the field this year, the last year his brother will be there?
Not everyone on the team supports Aiden. Brandon and his family support him, and his new friend Isabella supports him and might even be his first girlfriend.
We discover that Brandon has issues, too. He says, “I have to help everyone. Keep them laughing, keep them going, make them happy. I can’t be mad. I can’t be upset. I can’t be less. I have to be more. I have to stand out. Because then I can take up space.…I mean, I would get to take up my own space.…[Football] is the space where I’m the most important. Where everyone looks at me. Where everyone pays attention to me. I want [Aiden] there, of course, but the space still belongs to me.” He’s so good that scouts from universities are scheduled to watch him on the field.
The boys are out at a club and a white boy on the team starts a fight with Aiden. Aiden closes down. Brandon comes to his brother’s aid but by then the police have arrived and assault the black boys. Brandon is accused of attacking a policeman and is arrested. Aiden can’t remember what happened.
Brandon knows he’s innocent, but he’s suspended from the football team. His identity is fractured. While he’s in jail, his mother, a powerful lawyer, is making a case for him. But when the jury is assembled it’s completely white. Aiden was there at the club fight, but still can’t remember what happened. Tensions arise between the brothers.
Aiden discovers there’s a secret video of the event where the police beat the black boys. He must find and display that tape as proof of his brother’s innocence, but how?
The brothers realize that maybe Brandon’s hyped-up support of his younger brother is perhaps not the best for either of them. Maybe Aiden could reach his potential if he had to struggle for himself.
This page-turner earned the author, the William C. Morris YA Debut Award. It’s so worth reading, especially if you’re black, on the spectrum, concerned with racism or those on the spectrum. You won’t regret reading it.
Patricia Hruby Powell is the author of the award-winning books: Josephine; Lift As You Climb; Loving vs Virginia; and Struttin’ with Some Barbecue all signed and for sale at Jane Addams bookstore. Her forthcoming books are about bird migration, Martha Graham, Ella Fitzgerald, and waterfowl; as well as a paperback version of Loving vs. Viriginia releasing in 2027. talesforallages.com





